I was rather fortuitous to pick this up in a sale for an even more bargain price of £15.50, though its sold out now from where I bought it I did notice the set pop up on the online SpaceNK sale a few days ago.All the colours are from the permanent collection.
It includes Black Navy (shimmered navy with a charcoal base), Black Gold (shimmered antique gold with a hint of a charcoal base), Stormy Grey (charcoal grey), Black Violet (very dark, near black purple) and Brown Copper (shimmered warm brown).Swatches L-R: Black Gold, Brown Copper, Black Navy, Black Violet and Stormy Grey
I do tend to like the texture of these pencils as they are creamy with good pigment and wear well, however I was disappointed with Black Navy as I found it did not apply as smooth as the other shades and was lacking in pigment.I was hoping to be able to use these as lid shades as well but that went very wrong. On the lid I find them very hard to blend, they go patchy and even with a shadow primer they creased within an hour, so they are not as versatile as liners such as Rouge Bunny Rouge which I often use as lid shades.
Shown below, I really tried to work it with these to make the colours apply smooth with neat edges and it still ending up looking a mess. I've left this picture quite big so hopefully you can see the patchy application.

Ingredients:

I bought this from houseoffraser.co.uk

I can't believe Black Navy looks like that when swatched!! It looked so nice in the pencil close-up...what a let down! Patchy or not, your eye looks are always gorgeous, one day I'll have to pay you to fly over to do my makeup ;) !! I'm really interested in LM's Spring collection...any good? xx
ReplyDeleteHi Anna,
DeleteThank you, your such a sweet talker ;) Yes, you'd expect a nice bright blue from how Black Navy looks in the pencil. I've not yet seen the LM spring in real life (only Dior which was rather too pastel) I do think I'll end up getting some of the lip and cheek shades from LM, I've seen some nice pictures/reviews floating about for the peachy shades xx
Black Gold! It's too bad about Black Navy being not as good. I hate when that happens!
ReplyDeleteHi Vintage Makeup,
DeleteIt did promise a lot, mind you I can't really grumble though given the price :)
Great review and such a bargain for you! Your make-up looks fab also xx
ReplyDeleteHi Cat,
DeleteThank you :) It was a great price, I did well to nabb it I think as I am usually too slow when it comes to the sales ;)
Hey Replica! I think your eyemakeup and blending is stellar as always.. black gold looks like MAC Orpheus, no? This looks like a nice set to have, I've always wanted LM's Black turquiose and Black Jade eyekohls, do you have those?
ReplyDeleteHi Lakshmi,
DeleteYour too kind, I really didn't want to post it but felt the need to show that it wasn't much cop for use as eye shades.
I'm thinking its a bit more golden that Orpheus?
I really want black turquiose and Jade as well, I'm sure I have them on one of my to get lists ;) x